Most safety scorecards start with injury rates. They matter, but they tell you about the past, and at a small site they're mostly noise. Leading indicators measure the work that prevents the next injury. A good program uses both.
The difference
| Compared | Lagging indicators | Leading indicators |
|---|---|---|
| Measure | Harm that has already happened | Activities and conditions that prevent harm |
| Direction | Backward-looking | Forward-looking |
| Good for | Comparing with your industry, and long-term trends | Steering the program month to month |
| Weakness | Too late to act on, and noisy at small sites | Easy to turn into box-ticking |
OSHA puts it the same way in its guide Using Leading Indicators to Improve Safety and Health Outcomes.
Lagging indicators
- Total recordable incident rate (TRIR): recordable cases per 100 full-time workers.
- DART rate: cases with days away, restricted work or a job transfer.
- Lost-time incident rate (LTIR): cases with days away from work.
- Severity rate: days away and restricted per 100 full-time workers.
- Serious injuries and fatalities (SIF), and events reported to OSHA.
- Workers' compensation claims and costs.
The rates come straight from your OSHA log and hours worked. The incident rate calculator works them out and shows the formula.
Leading indicators
Good leading indicators are tied to your real risks, and each one points to an action. Some examples:
Reporting and learning
- Near misses and hazards reported per 100 workers
- Share of reports from frontline workers, not just supervisors
- Days from a report to the first response
Fixing problems
- Corrective actions closed by their due date
- Overdue actions, by risk level
- Repeat findings at the same place
Doing the planned work
- Planned inspections completed on time
- Training current for each role, and certificates about to expire
- Job hazard analyses reviewed in the last year
- Permits to work audited in the field
Leadership and involvement
- Leader safety walks completed
- Workers involved in inspections, JHAs or investigations
Choosing a balanced set
- Start from your biggest risks. If serious injuries would most likely come from forklifts, measure the controls that prevent forklift injuries.
- Pick a few. Three to six leading indicators that leaders review every month beat twenty that nobody reads.
- Pair them with outcomes. Keep your lagging rates to see whether the leading work is paying off over time.
- Measure quality as well as quantity. "Inspections done" means little if every one passes. Add "findings per inspection" or "actions closed".
- Review and change them. When an indicator is always green, it's stopped telling you anything.
ISO 45001 asks organizations to decide what to monitor and measure, and to evaluate their OH&S performance against it. A balanced set of indicators is how most do that. ISO 45001 9.1
Mistakes to avoid
- Rewarding low injury numbers. Bonuses or prizes for zero injuries can discourage reporting. Employers must have a reasonable reporting procedure and must not retaliate against employees for reporting. 1904.35
- Counting activity, not effect. A target for "50 observations a month" gets 50 observations, not 50 useful ones.
- Reading too much into small numbers. At a site of 50 people, one recordable case moves the TRIR by about 2. Look at trends over 12 months or more.
- Celebrating fewer near-miss reports. A drop often means people stopped reporting, not that the site got safer.